Comparing the Bid-Ask Spreads of Different SGX ETFs I Trade
Trading an SGX-listed ETF from Australia can look deceptively simple: place an order, receive units, and later sell them. The quiet cost sits in the difference between the highest price a buyer offers and the lowest price a seller accepts. On Financial MTC, I track that cost alongside CPF balances, savings rates, and other household cash movements because small market frictions deserve the same attention as larger ones.
This article records my process for measuring the bid-ask spread across several SGX ETFs rather than presenting fixed quotes that may be stale by the time you read them. The examples use SGD prices and the Singapore trading day, while the notes are aimed at Australian investors dealing with AUD funding, foreign brokerage statements, and the timing mismatch between ASX and SGX hours. These are personal observations, not professional financial advice.
Why Bid-Ask Spread Changes the Result
A bid is the highest price currently shown for buyers, while the ask is the lowest price shown for sellers. The midpoint sits between them, and the spread is the gap to be crossed when entering or leaving a position. If an ETF shows a bid of S$1.98 and an ask of S$2.02, buying at the ask and selling immediately at the bid creates a four-cent loss. That is 2% of the S$2.00 midpoint before brokerage or currency-conversion costs.
A quoted spread is only part of the bill, but it is also one of the most controllable pieces. The same distinction between headline value and usable value showed up in my premium durian price comparison: a small difference per piece became meaningful across several vendors and quantities. For an ETF, a narrow spread reduces the friction of both the opening and closing trade, while a wider spread raises the hurdle that the investment must clear.
The SGX ETFs on My Comparison List
I currently compare four familiar corners of the Singapore market. ES3, the SPDR Straits Times Index ETF, and G3B, the Nikko AM Singapore STI ETF, provide broad exposure to Singapore shares. O87, SPDR Gold Shares, gives access to a commodity rather than a local equity basket, while I98, the iShares MSCI India ETF, adds country-specific emerging-market exposure. Including products with different assets and trading hours makes the exercise more useful than looking at two similarly constructed funds.
Across my recurring snapshots, ES3 and G3B usually have the narrowest displayed spreads because local investors trade them heavily and their prices are tied closely to the Singapore trading session. O87 can remain inexpensive to trade when activity is steady, but its quote may react sharply when gold prices move overnight. I98 often carries a wider spread when local demand is thin or when the Indian market is closed. These are tendencies, not permanent rankings, and a one-cent gap in a S$10 ETF is not comparable with the same gap in a S$2 ETF.
Timing Matters More Than the ETF Label
Singapore’s regular securities session runs from 9:00 am to 5:00 pm SGT, with a midday break. For investors in Sydney and Melbourne, that window falls during the Australian working day: it opens around 10 or 11 am local time and closes around 6 or 7 pm, depending on daylight-saving rules. This makes a lunchtime check feasible for many Australians, although it is not the same live window available to someone sitting near the SGX market floor.
I take readings after the opening rush, around lunch, and again before the Singapore close, recording both the spread and the quantity shown at each price. A one-tick spread with substantial size is more dependable than an apparently tight quote supported by a single order. I also note whether the premium or discount to net asset value is moving. If the underlying market is closed or the local book becomes thin, waiting for a better quote can be more sensible than immediately crossing the spread.
Australian Costs Around an SGX Trade
The first adjustment for an Australian investor is currency. Most SGX ETFs trade in Singapore dollars, so an order funded from an AUD balance may involve an AUD-to-SGD conversion through the broker. Some Australian platforms offer a multi-currency cash account, while others convert automatically and add a fee. I compare the actual rate, including the markup, with a mid-market reference; two individually small charges can otherwise look like a single reasonable transaction cost.
The next adjustment is the brokerage statement. I check whether platform, commission, custody, and FX charges are quoted with or without GST, since treatment can vary by fee and provider. Australian residents also need to consider foreign income and capital-gains reporting rather than assuming the treatment will match an ASX-listed ETF. Distributions from SGX holdings may need to be declared, and the result of any capital gain can depend on whether the investment is legally classified as a CGT asset. For someone used to buying Australian banks such as CBA on the ASX, this extra reporting is a useful reason to check the broker’s statement and seek tax advice when the position becomes material.
Keeping a Reliable Spread Record
My spreadsheet has one row for every observation rather than one row per day. It captures the Singapore date and time, bid, ask, quoted sizes, traded volume, and the relevant Australian time. I calculate the spread in cents, then divide it by the midpoint and multiply by 10,000 to express it in basis points. The weekly median is more informative than a single reading, while the widest and narrowest observations show when trading urgency would have mattered.
The log also separates the quote from the outcome. A planned limit price, the actual fill price, the time taken to fill, and the FX rate all belong in the record. Otherwise, a tight quoted spread can create a false impression of cheap execution. This is the same distinction between a headline figure and cash actually available that appeared in my CPF housing refund experience, where the usable refund and its timing shaped the housing decision. Comparing the ETF data with the realised trade keeps the exercise grounded in personal cash flow.
Practical Rules for Cleaner ETF Execution
The useful output is not a league table but a set of repeatable choices. These are the rules I apply when trading from Australia:
- Start with the liquid local option. If the aim is Singapore-market exposure rather than a particular index, I compare ES3 and G3B first because their trading activity usually supports narrower quotes and better order-book depth.
- Use a limit order for a planned entry. I set the maximum price I will pay, commonly near the displayed ask, rather than sending a market order that could fill several ticks higher during a brief imbalance.
- Trade when both books are active. For me, that generally means avoiding the first minutes after the SGX open and checking the quote during the Australian lunch break or late Australian afternoon.
- Count the whole round trip. I estimate the spread, commission, and expected AUD/SGD conversion together. A modest spread in a frequently traded ETF may still be the cheaper route than a tighter-looking spread combined with a costly currency conversion.
- Review the result each week. I record whether my limit filled, at what price, and how long it took. The aim is to improve execution one small decision at a time rather than chase a quoted number.
A limit order does not guarantee a fill, and placing it too far from the market may leave an intended trade unexecuted. I therefore revisit the order book before adjusting the price, especially when an underlying overseas market is open and the ETF’s quote is moving quickly. If the position is urgent, accepting the spread may be rational; if it is not, patience can be part of the return.
Build a Two-Week Trading Journal
Create a small journal today and choose ES3, G3B, O87, and I98, or another manageable group of three or four SGX ETFs. Take a quote at the same three points on several Singapore trading days. Include the bid, ask, order sizes, midpoint percentage, and the Australian time, then note any actual order you place. Two weeks is long enough to reveal a pattern without turning the exercise into a full-time job.
At the end of the period, compare each ETF’s median and maximum spread with your realised fills and total AUD cost. This turns a static quote into a personal trading cost. It may also show that the widest-spread ETF still suits a long-term position, while another fund is better suited to a quick tactical trade.
Start with the four funds, the three daily snapshots, and one spreadsheet. Keep the first round descriptive rather than prescriptive, then let the evidence decide which ETF belongs in each part of your portfolio and which order style fits your patience.